Etiquette question: Bump old reviews when reporting on previously smok

Discussion in 'Cigar Reviews' started by SkyKing, Apr 13, 2012.

  1. SkyKing

    SkyKing New Member

    262
    0
    0
    Etiquette question: Last night I enjoyed the
    PDR 1878 CUBANO ESPECIAL CAPA MADURO ROBUSTO DOMINICAN REPUBLIC

    included in a CI sampler.

    I considered writing a review and also wanted to know what fellow CP members thought about the stick. Using search, I found that Scott1996 reviewed the cigar in May of 2010.

    While I enjoyed the stick from start to finish, I can't honestly add much more than a "me too" to his review but still wanted to recommend the cigar.

    I could either (a) write a new review from scratch or (b) bump the review with a few notes of my own. Is there an etiquette or community preference on this?

    Thanks to all CPrs by the way. Kind of fell in with the right bunch, I think.

    By the way, I give the "PDR 1878" a b+ in quality and an A in value.
     
  2. grateful1

    grateful1 Oh My!

    18,065
    80
    48
    For a review...do you own thread and maybe reference Scott's with a link to it!
     
  3. BlindedByScience

    BlindedByScience Proud Father of a brave U.S. Marine

    8,089
    319
    83
    I agree with Gary if you're doing a full review of a stick.

    On the other hand, I see nothing wrong at all bumping a thread if what you have to say is "...I agree with the original review...." and want to offer some impressions.

    No real hard and fast "rules" on this....use your own good judgement.

    JMHO, etc.....B.B.S.
     
  4. MilesMingusMonk

    MilesMingusMonk Breaking Wind Master

    3,099
    36
    48
    A simple "me too" response is just not worth bumping an older thread. If you can add some real substance to the original review, then bumping it is appropriate. A new review thread is always the best option, with a link to the older review to help keep a connection .
     
  5. BlindedByScience

    BlindedByScience Proud Father of a brave U.S. Marine

    8,089
    319
    83
    ...I guess I'm in the minority here.... :p
     
  6. MilesMingusMonk

    MilesMingusMonk Breaking Wind Master

    3,099
    36
    48
    Get with the program BBS! If you attended the monthly CP VIP meetings instead of those Interpersonal Modern Man seminars, you would already know the right answers.
     
  7. BlindedByScience

    BlindedByScience Proud Father of a brave U.S. Marine

    8,089
    319
    83
    I've never been invited to the CP VIP meetings, I'm still a plebe.... :p

    You are off base on the "Modern Man" seminars...way off. I usually spend my recreational time in those places where you can get a $5 steak dinner and spend lots of money, a dollar at a time..... :whistling:
     
  8. MilesMingusMonk

    MilesMingusMonk Breaking Wind Master

    3,099
    36
    48
    SkyKing....pictures are always welcome, especially of the label so others can more easily identify the cigar if they come across one. A lot of older reviews lack pictures because CP didnt have the convenience of the gallery uploads.
     
  9. Devil Doc

    Devil Doc When Death smiles, Corpsmen smile back

    10,142
    450
    83
    Cigar blends change. After two years a new review would be appropriate in my opinion.

    Doc
     
  10. Wurm

    Wurm Bratwurst and Beer

    6,117
    0
    0
    :thumbs: With a link to the old review as reference if you find one.
     

Share This Page