You really can not go wrong with any of the Van Winkle line(ORVW 10/107, PVWFR 12 LotB, PVWFR 15yr, 20 yr and the 23) but these can get $$ quick. Best bang for the buck is Elijah Craig 12 yr old about $20 bucks here in MI. If you're looking for something a bit sweeter I would go with any of the Weller line (Wheaters) the Special Reserve is very affordable for a 7yr old 90 proofer or if you like a kick the Weller Antique 107 has a bite but is very good. By all means if you can find a W.L. Weller Centennial 10 yr 100 proof grab it you will not be disappointed!
I would also second the Four Roses Single Barrel (100 proof), not a fan of the Small batch myself. The BT line up is all good stuff though some is a bit over priced in my area (AKA Hancock's Presidents reserve and the Rock Hill Farm :angry: )
Hope this helps!
Tony