Last night I tried the 1992 that Matt gave me. It was as smooth as he boasted.
Started off... great smell ou of the wrapper. Construction was excellent. Lighting it up, a nice, rich aroma wreathed my head and the initiall draw was mild but flavorful with a decent volumn of smoke that quickly developed into a volumn that filled the mouth with the lightest of draws. Burn was even and consistant with only a small tunnelling halfway though, that I attribute to leaving the 'gar outside when I went in for a restroom break for a fw minutes.
My palate is not well refined yet, but hints of cocoa and coffee seemed to build then fall as a rich oak tone took over for the last third of the smoke. Ash held well (about an inch or more each time) and probably only fell as early as it did because I was outside. I left about an inch to go when I had to pack it in (sprinklers were about to make it a wet smoking experience).
So, 90 minutes and 120+ pages later ( I usually read when I smoke alone) I had one good experience that I hope to repeat soon.