Which Juan Lopez is better?

[Gavin]

I have an opinion, just interested to see if there’s consensus.

 

[TexasTraveler]

I think option 3 is for me, because I haven't smoked enough of them to really tell a major difference, but if I had to choose I like JL1.

 

[CigarStone]

This one!

 

[BlindedByScience]

#2's are very, very good smokes for the price. Wasn't nearly as impressed by #1's. As they say, that's one guy's opinion.....

 

[IngloriousBasterd]

Haven’t had either of them so send me one or 2 of each so I can get back to you

 

[CgarDan]

No 2 has been better to me so far

 

[Thoughts]

Yes.

But No. 2 was one of my first cuban boxes bought and they were great. And the next box was. And the next one....and the next one....

 

[IngloriousBasterd]

Yes.

But No. 2 was one of my first cuban boxes bought and they were great. And the next box was. And the next one....and the next one....

You never forget your first

 

[MilesMingusMonk]

#2 would be my choice

 

[jfields]

#2 would be my choice

Well ain’t that some shite!

 

[ChuckJr]

Since I won a box of #1, I figure #2 will be the most popular

 

[kann]

Dos

 

[thinde]

I seem to reach for the #2's more than the #1's but I also seem to go through them both equally as fast.

 

[cohibasurfer]

I like the size of the No 1. A 46 ring is my sweetest spot.

 

[modo22]

2 has been the better option for me for boxes from 20 and 21. I did have a box of 19s No.1s that could make a case for the better smoke, but consistency wise, No.2s are my vote.

 

[tone-ny]

I've smoked several boxes of No. 2 and prefer them, especially aged. What was interesting is that I prefer the size of the No. 1 like Mike.

 

[H. Vachon]

You never forget your first

She turned out to be a bitch..

Wait, what are we talking about?

 

[xyz123]

Maybe I'm missing something.. what are people getting different from 2 over 1.. or vice versa? Maybe I just wasn't paying attention enough to notice a discernable difference in the two. 1 seemed to have a tad more strength to me, but that's it.

It's been at least a year or so since either, so I may not have the best memory to say with certainty.

 

[Gavin]

This turned out about how I expected.

Maybe I'm missing something.. what are people getting different from 2 over 1.. or vice versa? Maybe I just wasn't paying attention enough to notice a discernable difference in the two. 1 seemed to have a tad more strength to me, but that's it.

It's been at least a year or so since either, so I may not have the best memory to say with certainty.

I think the flavor of the #2 is better, and more approachable. Every time I smoke a #1, I end up wishing it was a #2.