I may be wrong, but I'm assuming you are talking about Cigar Aficionado. I don't have any experience with them specifically, but I do have some experience in these type of memberships. In my experience, any time you have an entity that is rating the goods of the companies that advertise in their magazine, the reviews tend to be a little bit skewed. :whistling: From what I've found, finding individuals who have no affiliation with the product who give reviews based on the actual merits of the product rather than advertising $$$ is a much better tool to use. I can't imagine that CA's insider membership will provide you with anything you can't already recieve from here, for free.
I'm not knocking CA, because personally I've never really bought their magazine or their membership. Most of my experience comes from the golf and guitar magazines. CA may be totally different.
Just my .02 cents.