Today's Smoke - Opinion - What I would like to see

JoeMO

JoeMO

Happy to be here
Joined
Dec 4, 2020
Messages
2,895
First Name
Seriously?
Just my personal opinion on what I would like to see if you post on Today's Smoke.
Write out the name of the stick - many times I can't tell what it is by just the band (old eyes). Please write what it is that you are smoking. I think most people do this.
Rate the smoke - I know our opinions vary quite a bit, but I would like to know if you recommend the smoke. Would you buy a box, a fiver, a stick, or won't ever need to smoke it again.
For example - DT&T Sin Compromiso, buy a box. Today I smoked a Blackbird Unkind and I would smoke one again, but wouldn't buy a box, so maybe a single or a fiver.
Obviously, whether you do this or not is up to you. I'm going to start trying to do both of these.
 
Last edited:
The written unwritten rule for 2021 was supposed to ask people to identify their cigars, at a minimum. It's definitely a good idea on the opinion side, though many of what I post I'd have to go back and edit later after I actually finish smoking it. I have no problem doing so. Just have to be careful that we aren't making the Reviews forum redundant, at that point.
 
I like this, I shall adopt this as well. The idea of would by a box, fiver, single or not smoke again is especially compelling. It seems more definitive than using a star rating system.
 
kann said:
The written unwritten rule for 2021 was supposed to ask people to identify their cigars, at a minimum. It's definitely a good idea on the opinion side, though many of what I post I'd have to go back and edit later after I actually finish smoking it. I have no problem doing so. Just have to be careful that we aren't making the Reviews forum redundant, at that point.
Click to expand...
I get it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top