Of the Maduro range, the Secretos are my favorite. To me, they have a more concentrated flavor that I won't grow tired of in 45 minutes.
thats an interesting take on the coh mad 5 line. ive wondered why the magicos and the genios dont get the love that the secretos engender. we move about 3-1 secretos - magicos. i always assumed it was about price point. perhaps, as you suggest, some smokers just get tired of the maduro flavor.
i have smoked several boxes of the magicos and about 20 or so genios. typically, both of these are well constructed, with rich flavors and dense, chewy smoke. these are not elegant cohibas. the secretos are fine and also offer some rich flavors. it just seems a bit too small to produce big flavor i want from the maduro.
when i want 40 x 110, i reach for a trini reyes.
cheers
drew p