I still feel bad about the JD Howard Reserve on the V-Herf. It is a cigar I usually enjoy quite a lot, but for some reason the one we all burned that night was very disappointing. I'd definitely give it a shot again, though, if you can get your hands on a few.
Las Calaveras was hit and miss for me. I really don't remember what year it was that I really, REALLY liked, but there was another year that I almost didn't finish the stick. I was wanting to try as many years' releases as I could have. If, by chance, they have previous Las Calaveras releases there, too, do not pass up the opportunity to grab one of each; if for nothing more than the experience of tasting the difference between the releases.
I have smoked a bunch of Jericho Hill (I believe there is/was only one vitola at the time, at least) and really dig them.
La Imperiosa should be in your wheelhouse.
Oddly enough, the one CH cigar I could just never get into was the Headley Grange; sad, considering the Led Zeppelin reference -- I wanted to love it.
www.neptunecigar.com
