How is he a defense dream client? A jury is going to want to castrate him. The fact that she "wasn't held against her will" by force might MIGHT help him, but anyone who will argue that psychological force is not enough to make it kidnapping, and not enough to make it wrongful imprisonment is a fool. She might not have thought that she was not free to leave (neccesary for WI), so in this instance it MIGHT be harder to get civil penalties than criminal, but I still think the case is a loser.
On top of that, I'm going to go ahead and guess that the janitor living with his parents doesn't quite have the moeny to be a "dream client."
Not to mention, anything that the courts can do to this man is not bad or harsh enough.
Edit: He was a security gueard, not a janitor, my apologies.