Name the Top 3 Cigars

[NickDavid]

Davidoff Millenium Churchill

Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur No. 1

CAO L Anniversaire eXtreme Belicoso

 

[emodx]

'98 Patagas Lusitania
Original Rlease Shark
Padron Millenium Maduro

 

[AVB]

Hard to find fault with those Emo but I'll replace the Shark with a Juan Clemente Churchill. I don't know why but I really like those.

 

[gatorsmg]

In no particular order

Padron Millenium
'98 Trinidad Fundadore
AF Anejo 50

 

[lucasbuck]

'01 Esplendido
'01 Lancero
'01 SLR DC

 

[Fast4Dr]

In no particular order.....

'85 Davidoff 5000
'94 RyJ Corona
Cohiba Corona Especiales Seleccion Reserva

 

[MonkeyK]

Upmann Sir Winston
Perdomo Edicion de Silvio
Anejo 55

all three were su-perb

 

[Matt R]

Cabinetta
Cabinetta
Cabinetta

 

[sir-smokes-a-lot]

Man, this is way too hard,

ISOM
'82 Punch Ninfa (on my birthday)
'98 Trinidad Fundadores


Domestic
Montecristo Serie V - torp.
Anejo Shark

 

[Lee]

Connies
El Credito (aged)
Papayos (aged)

 

[moki]

Opus X Maduro Lancero
Dunhill Estupendo '85
Ashton VSG ER

 

[golfgar]

The year is not over, but so far it looks like this:

Bolivar BF Cab May'01
Monte #2 Apr '03
Anjeo Shark

Sorry to all the others that didn't make the list. Honorable mention.......

RyJ Churchill 1998
Partagas 898 unvarnished 98
Hoyo de Dieux 1996
Padron 1964 maduro Pyramid

etc etc etc

 

[Maggs44]

Ashton VSG Robusto (aged a couple years by JOE, Im sure that helped it crack my top 3)

Opus X Perfection X (also aged a couple years by JOE)

Padron 64 Maduro Exclusivo

If anyone gets a chance to do a trade with JOE M. do it, he had some great, nicely aged smokes.

Edited to add one I forgot. I had a wonderful HdM 2003, Limited Edition I think, that I got from Tony Bones. That was just a great smoke.

Bruce

 

[ree ree robusto]

Cohiba Esplendido
Cohiba Robusto
PAM '26 No.9

 

[bigmac]

98 lusitania
anejo 55
H. Upman sir winston

 

[Eshaw99]

Montecristo #4 (aged a year in my humi)
Anejo Shark
Padron Serie 1926 No. 6 Maduro

and moki, how the hell did you come across an Opus Lancero maddie?

 

[Fast4Dr]

Cabinetta
Cabinetta
Cabinetta

[snapback]148701[/snapback]​

Look at me!!! Look at me!!!!!


HOMO

 

[dixieland_conjunction]

Top 3 Cubans:
Habanos Millineum
BBF 1999
CoRo 2001

3 Most consistent, kick-a$$ CHEAP Cuban smokes:
RyJ Coronitas en Cedro
Fonseca Delicias
Flor de Cano Tubalares

Top 3 NC:
LPH Black Pearl Grand Robusto
Aged AVO Signature
La Aurora Pref #2

3 Most consistent, kick-a$$ CHEAP NC smokes:
Genuine Pre-Embargo Counterfits
LPH Black Pearl Cobre Robusto
Flor de Oliva Grand Cameroon bells

Cheers,
Dixie

 

[CoventryCat86]

I probably smoked 1000 cigars over the course of the year, I have no idea ???

I remember the BAD ones more than the good ones since I had so many good ones and very few bad cigars.

Another reason this question is hard for me is because my tastes change, what I thought was a "killer" cigar six months ago is now way down on the list AND cigars I used to loathe are now high on my list TODAY but this may change next week.

Okay, favorites RIGHT NOW:

Saint Luis Rey Serie A '04 (much better than my 99's)
San Cristobal de La Habana El Morro (sometimes these REALLY tick me off when they're plugged but since I love the cigar so much, I'm much more patient with these and I go to great extremes to make them smokeable)
Opux X Reserva D'Chateau followed closely by a Fuente Fuente

Next year, I can guarantee the list will be completely different, maybe even next month :0

 

[Azon]

This is way to difficult to get a fair list of only three sticks. I cant do it but i can mention these:

Padron 64 (my first ever, must be mentioned)
Ashton VSG (You can allways count on them)
Avo 77, Intermezzo, Signature (i love AVO)
El Rey Del Mundo - Choix Supreme (ISOM)
RyJ EL 01 (i love these creature) (ISOM)
Montecristo - No.4 (a safe choice) (ISOM)
Quai D`orsay - Coronas (ISOM)
Partagas - Serie D No.4 (a powerpackage) (ISOM)

This is what i can come up withnow.