The Blind Taste Test Thread Comments

[Shibumi]

Mine was one of those you mentioned and I missed it. I anxious to see more results. C'mon people, light em up!

 

[Lumberg]

From a quick review of the comments made so far, I'm guessing the following numbers are all the same cigar:

49, 51, 53, 55, 57, 58a and 58b

Clues:

- cigar size
- ash color/density
- even/consistent burn
- sweet/citrus taste
- tougher draw
- sloppy cap

Based on these numbers, I'd hazard a guess that all cigars between 49 and 58 are the same. Lumberg, what do ya say?

[snapback]223387[/snapback]​

I had to stay silent until appropriate. You were dead on, steve.

I even wrote a review of this cigar way back in the day Would you pay under $1 a cigar for these?

recent cigarbid lot for these

I don't remember how much I paid myself.

 

[Lumberg]

So far as I can tell LC-smoker thought these were young, and AVB thought they were Nicaraguan (both dead wrong!)

 

[Lee]

more rockets.... :laugh:

 

[SamClemmons]

I like that someone started this thread. Now I don't have to pollute the other thread with "this is great, keep 'em coming@!" or "new identity revealed."

[snapback]223368[/snapback]​

Right. Now you can be more liberal with your pollution.... spread it around,ya know? Buwahahahahahahahahahaaaaaaaaaaaa. Ahem. lmao.

NA

 

[AVB]

Well....... not quite, what I said was:

It reminded me of Nicaraguan tobacco but I could be totally out in left field on that.

[snapback]217630[/snapback]​

So far as I can tell LC-smoker thought these were young, and AVB thought they were Nicaraguan (both dead wrong!)

[snapback]227623[/snapback]​

 

[Lee]

AVB, that was the hint of antifreeze....I'm sure it stumped a few of the others as well...LMAO :laugh:

 

[Lumberg]

Well....... not quite, what I said was:

It reminded me of Nicaraguan tobacco but I could be totally out in left field on that.

[snapback]217630[/snapback]​

So far as I can tell LC-smoker thought these were young, and AVB thought they were Nicaraguan (both dead wrong!)

[snapback]227623[/snapback]​

[snapback]227640[/snapback]​

True, I didn't do you justice.

 

[Lee]

Well....... not quite, what I said was:

It reminded me of Nicaraguan tobacco but I could be totally out in left field on that.

[snapback]217630[/snapback]​

So far as I can tell LC-smoker thought these were young, and AVB thought they were Nicaraguan (both dead wrong!)

[snapback]227623[/snapback]​

[snapback]227640[/snapback]​

True, I didn't do you justice.

[snapback]227649[/snapback]​

Open mouth, insert other foot....