Top 5 Non-Cuban cigars of 2009

[CigarInspector]

Thanks for participating in the poll! Here are the results for year 2009:

1. Tatuaje Noella Reserva
2. Padron 1926
3. Padron 45
4. La Aroma de Cuba Edicion Especial
5. Don Pepin Garcia My Father

Meant to post it in the Cigar Lounge. If somebody can move the topic, thank you

 

[tsmckenney]

Thanks for participating in the poll! Here are the results for year 2009:

1. Tatuaje Noella Reserva
2. Padron 1926
3. Padron 45
4. La Aroma de Cuba Edicion Especial
5. Don Pepin Garcia My Father

Meant to post it in the Cigar Lounge. If somebody can move the topic, thank you

I love the Noella, but a better smoke than the 45? Who took this poll?

 

[mufflerman]

I had a Reserva today and it was excellent. Haven't had the 45 so I can't compare, but the Tat was great!

 

[uptown_isy]

All the cigars on that list are EXCELLENT smokes. IMHO, the best of the year for CA will be the LFD Salomon and the Padron Family Reserve. I doubt it'll make the list, but I'm hoping the My Father 1922 Toro will make it, as well.

 

[jayro75]

All the cigars on that list are EXCELLENT smokes. IMHO, the best of the year for CA will be the LFD Salomon and the Padron Family Reserve. I doubt it'll make the list, but I'm hoping the My Father 1922 Toro will make it, as well.

Were the 1922's released early enough for consideration, Is?

 

[uptown_isy]

All the cigars on that list are EXCELLENT smokes. IMHO, the best of the year for CA will be the LFD Salomon and the Padron Family Reserve. I doubt it'll make the list, but I'm hoping the My Father 1922 Toro will make it, as well.

Were the 1922's released early enough for consideration, Is?

I believe they were, only I don't think they were rated. Did you see them rated anytime in the last couple of months?

 

[klipsch]

All the cigars on that list are EXCELLENT smokes. IMHO, the best of the year for CA will be the LFD Salomon and the Padron Family Reserve. I doubt it'll make the list, but I'm hoping the My Father 1922 Toro will make it, as well.

Were the 1922's released early enough for consideration, Is?

I believe they were, only I don't think they were rated. Did you see them rated anytime in the last couple of months?

IMHO...the DPG My Father doesn't belong on the list with the others there. The 1922 Le Bijou could have made it, but not the My Father. Just my opinion

 

[tomthirtysix]

Why are 2 of the top 5 specific cigars,and the other 3 are cigar lines?

 

[CigarDins]

The Tat and the 26 are amazing smokes. The My Father I didn't think was all that great. It was good but top 5, probably not IMO.

Haven't tried a 45 or the La Aroma.

 

[trogdor burninator]

Why are 2 of the top 5 specific cigars,and the other 3 are cigar lines?

Ditto. I've only smoked the Tatuaje on this list, so it'd be nice to know the specific size of the others to try.

 

[Golf&Puff]

I think the my father deserves the top over the la aroma de cuba, the le bijou really depends if you like that floral oscuro wrapper!? Epernay "smokes" 'em all to me!

 

[Not A Nice Person]

I think the my father deserves the top over the la aroma de cuba, the le bijou really depends if you like that floral oscuro wrapper!? Epernay "smokes" 'em all to me!

:thumbs:

Haven't had a less than terrific Epernay in any size/vitola yet. Fantastic cigars.

~Boar

 

[tomthirtysix]

I think the my father deserves the top over the la aroma de cuba, the le bijou really depends if you like that floral oscuro wrapper!? Epernay "smokes" 'em all to me!

Welcome back!

 

[Humidor Minister]

Had a TNR with a fellow member here a few weeks ago. I will say it was a great cigar. I really like the 1926 as well but haven't smoked both close enough together to make a comparason. Both are deserving of recognition. In the top 5, I'll have to think about that over a couple of them.

 

[Golf&Puff]

I think the my father deserves the top over the la aroma de cuba, the le bijou really depends if you like that floral oscuro wrapper!? Epernay "smokes" 'em all to me!

Welcome back!

Thank you, nice avatar! Merry CHRISTmas