Trader's Comments

[ggiese]

No, bad traders are quickly shown the door here and let's keep it that way. Besides it is Rod's house we don't make that call.

It is Rod's house... and he seems to spend an awful lot of time in the bathroom (with the water running )

That's MattR - making it look like it's Rod...

 

[ggiese]

OK, I've changed my mind...it's not needed at all.

How the hell did Giese get in here again!?! Will someone close that back door! :laugh:

You were in charge of keeping me out - some doorman you are... :sign:

 

[Ginseng]

All this talk about George invading Mr. Jerry's backdoor...I don't know. ???

Wilkey

 

[anvil]

What do you think this is - eBay??? :laugh:

Absolutely not!!! Trader's comments have absolutely nothing to do with being able to evaluate whether or not someone is trustworthy. The ones that are not trustworthy are long gone. The ones joining the board now that are going to be untrustworthy won't be here long either.. :whistling:

You want to know someone's reputation? Stick around and participate in the community. You'll know...

I tend to agree.
I had a problem with a Cigar vendor which involved confusing Emails/Track and Trace and slow delivery.
Only to find the problem was with USPS :angry:
My posting of a bad review on the vendor could have damaged his business when at the end of the day is was not his fault.
I say no the reviewing vendors.

 

[Dave]

Our actions speak for themselves.

Another thought against trader comments I think is relevant would be the possible collusion aspect. What's to stop people from giving false testimony in favor or against a certain trader?

 

[grateful1]

Our actions speak for themselves.

Another thought against trader comments I think is relevant would be the possible collusion aspect. What's to stop people from giving false testimony in favor or against a certain trader?

<ummm......GL!?! - it could happen!>

 

[Rod]

While I always take into consideration what the majority of the membership wants, I don't ever see trader comments being part of this community. They are easily manipulated, and definitely not something that can be relied upon. Your time here will prove whether you're to be trusted or not.

 

[Dave]

Our actions speak for themselves.

Another thought against trader comments I think is relevant would be the possible collusion aspect. What's to stop people from giving false testimony in favor or against a certain trader?

<ummm......GL!?! - it could happen!>

Weren't there four of them?