if you can - try plantation XO - you might like itDiplomático Reserva Exclusiva - pretty good
Brugal 1888 Doblemente Añejado - not bad, drinks more like a Burbon
Don Q Gran Reserva - only had 2 samples, need more time with it
Appleton rums are next up on my list
not sure I will try anything Plantation, got a bottle of OG Dark, and it wasn't even good for mixing
Was going to post this exact thing! I will add that I honestly don't think the XO Soleara are worth the huge price hike.Matusalem Gran Reserva & Zacapa 23 Solera are big favorites here.
~Boar
I have not, but it is on my listAppleton 12. It's a good gateway into Jamaican rums without being crazy.
Have you tried anything from Foursquare? As well as the Foursquare brand itself, Doorly's, Real McCoy, R.L. Seale, and Old Brigand are all distilled at Foursquare. Old Brigand is a bargain (believe it's a Total Wine exclusive).