Is Maker's Mark the best for the price point? I have to admit, that is the best bourbon I have tried.
I am a Macallan man though, still haven't found that special bourbon to compare with a good scotch.
My personal opinion: at the ~$25 price point, Evan Williams Single Barrell Vintage is the way to go. I also like the high-proof and the uplevel Wild Turkeys.
You should check out AVB's bourbon reviews for more ideas, as I'm not a huge bourbon fan (I tend to prefer scotch as well, unless I'm in the mood for bourbon), so I usually just get what's available to me locally, which ain't much.