• Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

Cigar Aficionado...help or hinderance

Lets be realistic here magazines are about selling ad space pure and simple. Have you ever read a bad review of any cigar in CA or that the car they just tested wasn't worth the $100K? Crap look at all the ads of for overpriced stuff that you don't really need are festooned for all to gawk at. They even have an ad for Macanudos which are some first class dog rockets, but if you look at the ad would make you run out and buy a box.

Now is the magazine itself a help or a hindrance? I would say only people that smoke cigars read or buy it. I've never seen anyone who doesn't smoke cigars have a subscription for it. I've never seen it a barber shop, or Drs.office (I’ve seen their Wine Mag at my dentist office).

Preembargo pegged it: “Whatever image CA presents, it's presented to its readers. The majority of the population has no idea what is inside the cover.”
 
I think magazines like CA & Wine Spectator do the "regular Joe" consumers like us a disservice. I often really have to wonder if some cigars would have the high price tag attached, if it were not for the ratings they get in some issues. I see it all the time with wine.
Robert Parker says it's a 95 rating, and then................BOOM! I can't afford to buy that bottle anymore.
 
I read CA for many years but quit reading it 5 years ago because there was just too much evidence that the rating your cigar gets is directly proportional to the amount of money you spend advertising in the magazine.

I know everybody's taste is different but when a $3 MSRP cigar gets a 91 rating (which is an average of multiple peoples scores) there is just something wrong.

As far as helping or hurting our cause, I don't CA represents reality so it probably doesn't help us too much.
 
Top