I've had a few of the Casa Magnas, this exact size, and I have to say it was just good...not great...not spectacular....not number 1! Of course, everyone I had was overfilled and had a tight draw that produced little smoke AND required way too much effort to smoke.
I guess I'll have to revisit this one again.
But seriously, No.1? How can a 96pt cigar come in 2nd, and a 93pt cigar come in first, when it's a "blind" tasting??? Price should have no bearing in this rating if it's truly blind (which it's really not considering a seasoned smoker can tell cigars from eachother without bands).
Just my .02.
BTW, thanks for the contest.