OK, here are some newer ones for ya.
No Rain - Blind Melon
More Than Words – Extreme
Everything About You -Ugly Kid Joe
Far behind - Candle Box
Possum Kingdom - Toadies
i'll be there (friends theme) - The Rrembrants
I Ran - Flock of Seagulls
Tones of Home was Blind Melons first major hit, and Change was almost bigger than both put together (although No Rain still gets a lot of play).
Extreme had a bunch of hits, although the ballads were big sellers at that time so most people only remember that song.
Ugly Kid Joe did a great cover of Cat's in the Cradle that was a huge hit (bigger than anything they wrote themselves)
That was actually Candlebox's second big hit - You was quite popular for a while (aside note - my brother was sitting next to the singer on a plane from NY to Cali when my brother's band was on their way to Australia to do the Warped Tour - just when Candlebox was getting big with Far Behind)
Toadies (see below)
The Rembrandts first hit was Just the Way It Is, Baby and until Friends came along it was a bigger hit than I'll be there for You.
Flock of Seagulls had a bunch of big songs - more than most bands of that era/genre (Telecommunication, Space Age Love Song, Wishing [If I Had a Photograph of You], etc)
Possum Kingdom - Toadies
Toadies also had a hit called Tyler, well maybe not a "big" hit, but it was OK popular IMO.
"I come from the water" was a fairly big hit off that first album as well
So Alive - Love and Rockets
I Touch Myself - The Divinyls
"No New Tale to Tell" and "Ball of Confusion" were huge hits for Love and Rockets (amoung others).
The Divinyls had 2 other singles off that album, but only one got much play - and they both sucked
Blur - Woo Hoo, but I think it was called Song #3
Blur had quite a few big hits (most notably She's So High and Girls & Boys) Song 2 was popular long after after they hit it big with There's No Other Way (Still their best song)
Here's a nice obscure one:
Urban Dance Squad - Deeper Shade of Soul
James- Laid
Oh heck - I have drawers full of new wave brit pop/punk that is nothing but one hit wonders (and most won't even be recognized)
A lot of those weren't one hit wonders, but I gotta say I do like you're taste in music
(how can you call Faith no More a one hit wonder?!?

)