I just read the thread on the Torano site that is the genesis of all of this... as well as his posts on CW. The guy is definitely a scumbag.
Repeated attempts at mooching cigars, attempts to butt into a pass it forward (despite being told numerous times he was not yet qualified to join), culminating in ripping off the Torano box pass.
The box was sent to him via priority mail on 3/12, Archmage1 posted as receiving it on 3/15... then on 3/20 he posted claiming all manner of various personal problems (flooded basement, etc) as the reason for the delay, and that was it. Meanwhile he continued to post on CW until 3/24 despite ignoring emails and posts from the box pass participants on the Torano web boards.
After that, it looks like he just disappeared from Torano, as well as CW.
Once he was "outed" on Torano he stopped posting there, and then on CW he was "outed" a few days later, and he magically stopped posting there as well.
Draw your own conclusions, I guess, but it seems pretty clear to me that the guy is a dirtball...