• Come celebrate the vHerf's 5 year anniversary!
    * * * Saturday Night, May 31 * * *
    5:00 PM Pacific / 8:00 PM Eastern

    If you've never participated in the vHerf, now's your chance!

    Click here to enter...

Hometown Pass

I made some adjustments. Let me know if these P/T's are good.

1 DPG Outlaw Custom Wanlail
58 Cabiguan Guapo MP
8 LFD Mysterio Oscuro Wanlail
59 Tatuaje Black (Jar) MP
25 Bolivar Royal Corona '07 Wanlail
60 Cohiba Corona Especiales 06' MP
27 Rafael Gonzalez Marquez 06'Wanlail
61 Partagas 898 Varnished 04' MP
46 Fonseca Cosaco SmokinTexas
62 Rafael Gonzalez Corona Extra 01' MP
 
I realize that the P/T's are still tentative, but I went ahead and updated the Google Doc (<-- Link)

Also, it looks like Kevin put the addresses on sheet 2 which can be found at the bottom of the document.
 
My apologies for not mentioning the issue with the bag. The top came torn up pretty good and I taped it up as a quick fix to keep this moving. It looked like USPS roughed the box up on the way over. I tried to focus on cleaning up the outside of the box and getting all the edges sealed tight.
 
Haha THATS what your last name is. :) I couldn't figure it out. You just sent me your address, no name. Robbie's P/T look good to me.

Well, new note to self: Next Pass, I need to put the cigars into a shatter proof box!
 
Yup and I have heard it all with that name too :sign:

wanlail said:
Haha THATS what your last name is. :) I couldn't figure it out. You just sent me your address, no name. Robbie's P/T look good to me.

Well, new note to self: Next Pass, I need to put the cigars into a shatter proof box!
Click to expand...
 
One of my dad's low-level expressions of exasperation is "frick my frack".

Here are my proposed Takes and Puts:

Take 5 Vegas Limitada 2006; Put AF King B
Take Davidoff Robusto Intenso 2006; Put Padron 1926 #2 Maduro
Take White Owl Invincible '52; Put Tatuaje Reserva J21
Take AF Opus xXx; Put Tatuaje Zona del Este
Take Tatuaje Cohete; Put My Father Robusto (#1)
Take Tatuaje Black; Put La Flor Dominicana Factory Press II
 
The Green Monkey said:
One of my dad's low-level expressions of exasperation is "frick my frack".

Here are my proposed Takes and Puts:

Take 5 Vegas Limitada 2006; Put AF King B
Take Davidoff Robusto Intenso 2006; Put Padron 1926 #2 Maduro
Take White Owl Invincible '52; Put Tatuaje Reserva J21
Take AF Opus xXx; Put Tatuaje Zona del Este
Take Tatuaje Cohete; Put My Father Robusto (#1)
Take Tatuaje Black; Put La Flor Dominicana Factory Press II
Click to expand...
Two trades stuck out for me,
xXx for Tat
Tat Black for Factory Press

Brian
 
br174 said:
The Green Monkey said:
Take AF Opus xXx; Put Tatuaje Zona del Este
Take Tatuaje Black; Put La Flor Dominicana Factory Press II
Click to expand...

Two trades stuck out for me,
xXx for Tat
Tat Black for Factory Press
Click to expand...

I think the first might reach, since the Zona Del Este isn't made anymore and was a limited release when it was. MSRP was about the same, too, I think.

But the LFD II was about $2 less than the Tat Black when it was released, IIRC.

Everything else looks good.

~Boar
 
The xXx MSRP is $9.25 according to MMM's thread (click) and the Zona del Este's MSRP was $10 according to Vitolas (click).

As far as the LDF FP II, when I valued it for Jonesy's noob pass back in the fall, I came up with an average of $12.50 based on the price at the few places that still had them in stock at the time--Jack Schwartz ($12.25; now out of stock), Atlantic ($12.50; now out of stock), and $12.75 still in stock at What's Knot to Love (click). Arnold's (click) has it in stock now for $12, and every review I've found for it lists MSRP at $12. I did, however, find it now for $10.80 at Show Me Your Ash (click) so if that's a deal-breaker, I certainly understand.

Vitolas lists the MSRP of the Tat Black at $12 (click).

I'm not being defensive or argumentative, and I'll certainly try to rework one or both if necessary--just explaining the manner in which I arrived at my valuations and proposals...
 
The jar Blacks have always been listed at $13, though. That's the figure I had in my head when I posted---wasn't meaning to come down on you by any means; didn't know the bundle Blacks priced out a buck less.

The Show Me Your Ash link does bring up a point to consider, though---that market price on the FP II is actually falling, whereas the opposite is happening for the Blacks.

~Boar
 
I didn't realize that the Black values were different depending on jar or bundle--the one in the pass is from a jar, not a bundle, so the bundle pricing of $12 may be wholly irrelevant anyway...

Holts has the LFD FP II at $59.95/5 (click), Hiland's has them for $15 apiece (click), and Serious has them for $12 apiece (click) so Show Me Your Ash seems like a bit of an outlier. I didn't examine anything beyond the top 20 google results though.

Edit-->If it's any more palatable to Kevin and the rest of the group, I'm certainly willing to scratch the Tat Black-->LFD FP II swap in favor of a Cuvee Grand Lancero '06--> LFD FP II swap...
 
How about I scratch the LFD PF II--> Tat Black p/t and instead take the Cuvee Grand Lancero '06 for the LFD FP II?

How does that sound?
 
Contest package was at my house today and I can't say thank you enough for the assault on my wish list. Far too generous! :thumbs:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top