I just wanted to chime in among the rivalry and say that I appreciate the comments about the War…both in support and opposing the idea. To call it what it is, it was a bit of Noob coming out of me. The only thing I want to ‘defend’ is that I did have good intentions in posting this thread. CP is an amazing board and even among the bs rivalry smack talk, there is an obvious sense of camaraderie. The War was just going to be another way to give back. Regaurdless, thanks to all for commenting. If nothing else, it was another learning experience for me.
Let me just say, since I did post opposition, that I don't think your idea is necessarily bad, and 6-8 months from now I think it might get some play. I won't pretend to speak for Bruce, but what I took from his post was this: The newbie war is still going on to an extent, right before that was the Blizzard, and 8 months before that was the newbie war '08. Just seems like a lot of non-stop bombing, and while that is part of our community, I feel like it's becoming the overwhelming part of our community. It shouldn't be. I'm all for Paying it Forward, etc. but for me personally I'm afraid that people that may have joined in the last few months might be getting the impression that the way to "fit in" in this community is to joining a bombing war, and then draw attention to it. There is absolutely nothing wrong with bombing someone, I do it often, but the main point to bombing someone is to thank them for some knowledge they've shared with you, or to say thank you, to show appreciation, or to share something that you can access that maybe they can't. It can also be a way to help a person who is down, or share in their joy. But the main point to bombing, at least for me, is it's a chance to really get to know someone and what they like. When/if I decide to bomb someone I take some time to read some old posts of theirs to get a sense for things they like. Be it the type of cigar they like, or a beer, or some coffee, or a little something for their kid, etc. Through that you get a sense of connection with the person you bomb. These wars are fun, and I particpated in one myself when I first started here. I guess my point is just make sure when you are bombing, or having one of these wars that the people you target are people you truly have a respect and appreciation for, and use it as a way to help form a bond.
Whew, I feel like Will Ferrell after the debate scene in Old School. I think I blacked out there for a second. :laugh: