Rating Cigars and More...Much More

[PunchLibertad4Me]

http://www.cigarresearch.com/Site/ICRS.html

 

[MrErskine]

Thank you for that. I have been looking for a better way to organize my thoughts than just writing a narrative.

 

[SiriusBlack]

This is pretty cool. Thanks.

 

[Anthem]

Very interesting.

I might disagree with the idea that you can tell much about the cigar from smelling it untorched, especially in a B&M walk in humidor.

It is only my humble opnion, but I would love to know what other brothers find in this case.

 

[MrErskine]

Very interesting.

I might disagree with the idea that you can tell much about the cigar from smelling it untorched, especially in a B&M walk in humidor.

It is only my humble opnion, but I would love to know what other brothers find in this case.

I haven't had too much problem being able to isolate a scent in a walk-in humidor. There have only been a couple times when when I sensed in a walk-in changes to when I am outside. I'm probably just weird, I don't know.

 

[bigmanfromou]

Interesting info. Thanks.

 

[Marco-Polo]

I tend to use this Credo "phases of tasting" guide when reviewing a smoke - it's not a rating profile, of course, but it definitely helps to organize my thoughts.

http://www.credo.fr/uk/monde_credo_world/degustation_uk.htm