All reviews are in... tabulating and commenting... will post shortly!
Welcome to the joys of blind taste tests, and the inconstancy and individual nature of taste!
Absolutely. My poor smoke was almost completely plugged by the time I gave up. I'm afraid drawing as hard as I had to made the stick burn hot, masking a lot of it's taste.The two who scored it the lowest (Insight and BlindedByScience) noted that the draw was tight... I bet that affected the rating somewhat.
The size didn't seem quite right but I could come up with a cigar at the time. The sad truth is that I should have nailed the origin and brand because I love Cabaiguan. I got a box of Robusto Extra, Guapo and Imperiales in my humidor! I wonder if Pete would have got it!
Moki - The Original Cigar Forum Rock Star