The Kidneys and Left Nuts Official Pass Thread

cabaiguan juan

Sparkles on a Rainbow
Joined
Aug 30, 2006
Messages
4,681
So here are my initial P/T's. Please let me know your thoughts one these.
T: #1 DE Undercrown Corona Viva
P: Protocol Blue Corona Gorda

T: #18 Tat Havana VI Angeles
P: Brickhouse Maduro Robusto

T: #40 AF Rosado Sungrown Magnum R52
P: Roma Craft Aquitaine EMH - I wasn't real sure on the price for the AF so I to refer to Thompson's or JR and so I'm a little unsure of the evenness of this trade.

T: #47 Pepin Cuban Classic 1952 Sept. 2007
P: FSG Robusto - I dont know if the price difference makes up for the age, but I thought I would toss this one out there for comment.

T: #67 Davidoff Yamasa Robusto
P: Davidoff W.C. The Late Hour churchill
 

bluue13

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
3,084
So here are my initial P/T's. Please let me know your thoughts one these.
T: #1 DE Undercrown Corona Viva
P: Protocol Blue Corona Gorda

T: #18 Tat Havana VI Angeles
P: Brickhouse Maduro Robusto

T: #40 AF Rosado Sungrown Magnum R52
P: Roma Craft Aquitaine EMH - I wasn't real sure on the price for the AF so I to refer to Thompson's or JR and so I'm a little unsure of the evenness of this trade.

T: #47 Pepin Cuban Classic 1952 Sept. 2007
P: FSG Robusto - I dont know if the price difference makes up for the age, but I thought I would toss this one out there for comment.

T: #67 Davidoff Yamasa Robusto
P: Davidoff W.C. The Late Hour churchill
AF for RoMa Craft looks good to me
Pepin for FSG value wise looks ok to me as well...though I don't know a ton about the FSG. Anyone else definitely feel free to weigh in.
 

jfields

Where did all my money go?
Joined
Jan 25, 2007
Messages
12,945
AF for RoMa Craft looks good to me
Pepin for FSG value wise looks ok to me as well...though I don't know a ton about the FSG. Anyone else definitely feel free to weigh in.
What’s a FSG? Fuente Sun Grown?
 

cabaiguan juan

Sparkles on a Rainbow
Joined
Aug 30, 2006
Messages
4,681
The box arrived today. I will inspect it tomorrow. I have a few more P/T's to add if y'all don't mind:.

T: #14 AF Flor Fina 8-5-8 toro
P: Oliva Serie V #4 corona

T: #52 Tat Victorias
P: Oliva Serie V Melanio #4 corona

T: #13 AF Flor Fina 8-5-8 Candela
P: Perdomo Firecracker (https://thecigarauthority.com/perdomo-firecracker-cigar-review/)

Let me know what you guys think.
 

cabaiguan juan

Sparkles on a Rainbow
Joined
Aug 30, 2006
Messages
4,681
Ok, two more P?T's. This is the last, I swear.

T: #12 DE Herrera Esteli Miami Short Corona
P: EL GUEGUENSE CORONA GORDA

T: #62 Tatuaje TAA 2018
P: EL GUEGUENSE THE WISE MAN TORO MADURO
 

modo22

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2009
Messages
4,192
Pepin for FSG value wise looks ok to me as well...though I don't know a ton about the FSG. Anyone else definitely feel free to weigh in.
Not sure on this one either only because I think the age plays into it.

T: #62 Tatuaje TAA 2018
P: EL GUEGUENSE THE WISE MAN TORO MADURO
Not sure on this one. But I am trying to take my personal opinion out of it. I think the Tat is a way better and harder to find cigar, but I know nothing about the El Gueguense.
 

cabaiguan juan

Sparkles on a Rainbow
Joined
Aug 30, 2006
Messages
4,681
Not sure on this one either only because I think the age plays into it.


Not sure on this one. But I am trying to take my personal opinion out of it. I think the Tat is a way better and harder to find cigar, but I know nothing about the El Gueguense.
I don’t know how to monotone the age on the Pepin, so I thought if I put the FSG with its higher dollar value, it would compensate for the aged smaller Pepin.
for the Tat, your right that it is harder to find, but given they are roughly the same age- I got the Wiseman in early 2019, that the dollar value is your essentially the same $12 vs $12.20 (i think, I’m doing this from memory) that it would be close enough to equal, but this is why I wanted to seek advice and input.
 

bluue13

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
3,084
I don’t know how to monotone the age on the Pepin, so I thought if I put the FSG with its higher dollar value, it would compensate for the aged smaller Pepin.
for the Tat, your right that it is harder to find, but given they are roughly the same age- I got the Wiseman in early 2019, that the dollar value is your essentially the same $12 vs $12.20 (i think, I’m doing this from memory) that it would be close enough to equal, but this is why I wanted to seek advice and input.
Overall they all look good to me except for the Tat TAA/Wiseman trade. I feel like the tat is much more of a limited stick that it sets it apart a bit from a regular production stick. If you've got your heart set on the tat maybe you have a LE or other HTF stick that might make a better trade?

Any other thoughts from anyone?
 

cabaiguan juan

Sparkles on a Rainbow
Joined
Aug 30, 2006
Messages
4,681
Overall they all look good to me except for the Tat TAA/Wiseman trade. I feel like the tat is much more of a limited stick that it sets it apart a bit from a regular production stick. If you've got your heart set on the tat maybe you have a LE or other HTF stick that might make a better trade?

Any other thoughts from anyone?
I had a back up for the Tat/wiseman exchange so let me float that out.
T: Ashton VSG Corona Gorda- I do t recall the number but is the one that Chester just put in
P: Thw Wiseman Madurai Toro.
 

bluue13

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
3,084
So here are my initial P/T's. Please let me know your thoughts one these.
T: #1 DE Undercrown Corona Viva
P: Protocol Blue Corona Gorda

T: #18 Tat Havana VI Angeles
P: Brickhouse Maduro Robusto

T: #40 AF Rosado Sungrown Magnum R52
P: Roma Craft Aquitaine EMH - I wasn't real sure on the price for the AF so I to refer to Thompson's or JR and so I'm a little unsure of the evenness of this trade.

T: #47 Pepin Cuban Classic 1952 Sept. 2007
P: FSG Robusto - I dont know if the price difference makes up for the age, but I thought I would toss this one out there for comment.

T: #67 Davidoff Yamasa Robusto
P: Davidoff W.C. The Late Hour churchill
The box arrived today. I will inspect it tomorrow. I have a few more P/T's to add if y'all don't mind:.

T: #14 AF Flor Fina 8-5-8 toro
P: Oliva Serie V #4 corona

T: #52 Tat Victorias
P: Oliva Serie V Melanio #4 corona

T: #13 AF Flor Fina 8-5-8 Candela
P: Perdomo Firecracker (https://thecigarauthority.com/perdomo-firecracker-cigar-review/)

Let me know what you guys think.
Ok, two more P?T's. This is the last, I swear.

T: #12 DE Herrera Esteli Miami Short Corona
P: EL GUEGUENSE CORONA GORDA

T: #62 Tatuaje TAA 2018
P: EL GUEGUENSE THE WISE MAN TORO MADURO
I had a back up for the Tat/wiseman exchange so let me float that out.
T: Ashton VSG Corona Gorda- I do t recall the number but is the one that Chester just put in
P: Thw Wiseman Madurai Toro.

Just trying to condense everything into one spot here so I can keep it organized.

So I think this looks good?
 

bluue13

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
3,084
@cabaiguan juan just want to double check you've numbered your puts in the order that they're listed here? If not, just confirm for me what they are.
 

cabaiguan juan

Sparkles on a Rainbow
Joined
Aug 30, 2006
Messages
4,681
So here is my numbered P's:

75. Protocol Blue Corona Gorda
76. Brickhouse Maduro Robusto
77. RoMa Craft Aquitaine EMH
78. FSG Robusto
79. Davidoff Winston Churchill Latehour Churchill
80. Oliva Serie V #4 Corona
81. Oliva Serie V Melanio #4 Corona
82. Perdomo Firecracker
83. El Gueguense Corona Gordo
84. The Wiseman Maduro Toro

shit that is a long list and a lot of typing.
 
Top