Which is your favorite corona gorda?

[mata777]

I"ll start off with my take. For me it's a close tie between SLR serie A and HdM #1.

 

[wkoti]

Tatuaje Black Jar Release and Illusione ECCJ

 

[Backslide]

Ramon Allones Superiores by a country mile.

 

[Bsneed51]

Juan Lopez No.1, or Punch Punch, but maybe H. Upmann Mag 46, then again Punch Royal Selection 11, oh I almost forgot about SLR A.......damn how do you pick just one?


By far my favorite cigar size.

 

[punk_lawyer]

Juan Lopez No.1, or Punch Punch, but maybe H. Upmann Mag 46, then again Punch Royal Selection 11, oh I almost forgot about SLR A.......damn how do you pick just one?


By far my favorite cigar size.

Mark this day in history!!! I agree with Brent across the board on all of these. Has hell frozen over? Are pigs flying? What is this world coming to when Brent and I agree completely.

Seriously though, Brent's list is spot on.

 

[thinde]

Siglo 4 does it all day long for me.

 

[Raodwarior]

SLR Serie A or Mag 46

 

[Bsneed51]

Juan Lopez No.1, or Punch Punch, but maybe H. Upmann Mag 46, then again Punch Royal Selection 11, oh I almost forgot about SLR A.......damn how do you pick just one?


By far my favorite cigar size.

Mark this day in history!!! I agree with Brent across the board on all of these. Has hell frozen over? Are pigs flying? What is this world coming to when Brent and I agree completely.

Seriously though, Brent's list is spot on.

You're getting smarter in your older age. It takes a while to realize I'm always right, but they usually all come around.

 

[golfgar]

Serie A

Mag 46's just haven't been there for me, the quality is too spotty.

 

[Pipe Smoker]

Mag 46

 

[grateful1]

More of a Gand Corona:
La Flor de Cano Gran corona - only had two of these iirc - niccca smoke!
PSD3 EL 2006
Monte C El 2003


N/C
Casa Fuente CG
OR Tat Black (jar release) - Hi Tone!
Davidoff 5000 - one of the Davi's NOT of the Millenium line that I enjoy.

 

[siriusstoogie]

SLR A and mag 46 with at least few years on them.

 

[thechenman]

It's not current production, but I find it tough to beat a good Bolivar Corona Extra.

 

[MarkJr]

I would haave to go with the Juan Lopez Selecion #1 for ISOM, and Tat Black Jar release and FFOX Fuente Fuente tie for NC

 

[likescarsz28]

If you asked me once a week for 6 months, you might get a diffferent answer every week.

 

[dvickery]

only open box i have just now of this size(so by default my current favorite)...upmann super coronas.

derrek

 

[amitsachdeva]

Corona Gorda, It is happens to be one of my most favorites. This size is often referred Toro. It is 5 5/8 by 46 ring gauge.

 

[rawrr]

SLR A in cab is my favorite.

 

[TFJ]

Indeed, how do you choose just one?
 
I enjoy;
 
Juan Lopez No. 1
Cohiba Siglo IV
H. Upmann Magnum 46
Punch Royal Selection 11
Romeo y Julieta Exhibicion No. 3
Saint Luis Rey Serie A
 
Not in that particular order, but I would say that the Juan Lopez is my favorite most of the time, and I have a box of 06 RyJ Ex. No. 3 that was one of the top five cigars I smoked last year! Mag 46 are excellent most of the time, but 05, 08 and 11 have been hit or miss for me. I also picked up a five pack of 08 Punch RS 11 last year that are truly excellent. Unfortunately, these were discontinued in 2010  :angry:.
 
My apologies for rambling on, but I just can't pick one! 

 

[mk05]

Super Corona and ERDM