• Hi Guest - Come check out all of the new CP Merch Shop! Now you can support CigarPass buy purchasing hats, apparel, and more...
    Click here to visit! here...

Vegas Series 'A' maduro

I like 'em (the 'A's that is)... in fact I smoked one last night at work.

But I'll never buy another box of them... Padrón 2000 Maddies are soooooo much better and not much more a stick.
 
coventrycat86 said:
bilder said:
Gentlemen,

This sounds like the perfect time for an experiment.

I suggest you each send a blind 5er to each other. 5 sticks, bands removed and numbered. Do not send the bands. Let the review be one that is totally blind.

Include premo sticks and value cigars in the 5er. Both of you smoke the sticks, write and post a review. After the review is posted, the sender will reveal which cigar the reviewer had smoked.

This way you can each have some fun rather than argue and the rest of us can witness the battle of the tastebuds.
Click to expand...

Please resist the urge to play "peacemaker" or moderator.

This guy owes me and the entire community an apology and the sooner off he realizes that, the better off he'll be.
Click to expand...

Not trying to play any role here. Just seems you guys are debating what the results of a blind taste test would be. I merely suggested you put your words to the test.

As for Wade owing an apology, I would ask for what? He stated his opinion, same as you. I am not offended by the opinions of either of you so why should either of you say you are sorry? One of you likes a cigar, the other thinks it is crap. Big deal.

I think Victor Sinclair is crap, yet there are others who like them. Should I demand an apology to the guy who likes them and thinks that I would in a blind review? Who cares! Smoke what you like.
 
Wurm said:
I like 'em (the 'A's that is)... in fact I smoked one last night at work.

But I'll never buy another box of them... Padrón 2000 Maddies are soooooo much better and not much more a stick.
Click to expand...
Arent all the Padron thousand series maddies good! I got a box of each. I will get a box of the A's on C-bid from time to time if I get them cheap enough. The last was a box of the churchills for $38 + shipping. At that price I'll buy a box.
 
The Volusianator said:
CC, maybe it was the way I worded my initial post in this thread. I didn't mean that "most" people would like the smoke if they tried it blind, but rather that if "most" people tried it blind, there would be more positive reviews. I hope I worded that better this time, rereading my original post, I can see how it may have been taken the way in which you replied to it.

As far as the "personal attack", I made no personal attack, just an observation of posts "I've read" of yours. Trust me, if I made a personal attack, (which I wouldn't because I'm just not that kind of a guy) you'd know it. The term "personal attack" is so overused on web forums, there's a huge difference between personal attack and an observation, I made the latter. :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

Don't try and bullshit your way out of this one. :rolleyes: Here's what you said, and it is indeed a "personal attack"
You know, I'm new here and I really don't know your past, but I don't think I've read a post of yours yet where you had a decent attitude. Not sure what crawled up your ass and died, but a trip to the toiley to rid yourself of it would'nt hurt.
Click to expand...

This was completely uncalled for and you should apologize for this, don't you think?
 
These are not the droids you're looking for....move along....move along.
 
The Volusianator said:
Wurm said:
I like 'em (the 'A's that is)... in fact I smoked one last night at work.

But I'll never buy another box of them... Padrón 2000 Maddies are soooooo much better and not much more a stick.
Click to expand...
Arent all the Padron thousand series maddies good! I got a box of each. I will get a box of the A's on C-bid from time to time if I get them cheap enough. The last was a box of the churchills for $38 + shipping. At that price I'll buy a box.
Click to expand...

Na... I only have a small 120 humidor. 5ers maybe, but no longer a full box of the 'A's. My tastes have moved on.
 
Hey no fair, Wade's starting arguments with Bill just to pad his post count! :(
 
The Volusianator said:
You know, I'm new here and I really don't know your past, but I don't think I've read a post of yours yet where you had a decent attitude. Not sure what crawled up your ass and died, but a trip to the toiley to rid yourself of it would'nt hurt.

I'm simply saying that we all have different tastes, that's fact. I like the 5 Vegas Serie A you don't, that's fact. I don't care for Davidoffs, that's fact. None of those things are disputable, however I still believe that given blind taste tests, a lot of cigar smokers would enjoy cigars in general that they "think" they don't like, if they didn't realize what it was going in and had an open mind. Now of course that is disputable, but it is my opinion...for what it's worth. I'm entitled to mine, you're entitled to yours, I have no problems with that.
Click to expand...



Yup... Very true... You're new here and you don't know CC's past... ;)



Hey, smurfie... You insinuating Bill's a Cylon warrior or suntin'? :cool:
 
BTW - you can start your blind taste test at my house. Vol guy - as long as you're not a going to be smokin' the Davidoff ' cause you're not a fan - go ahead and send me a Davidoff and a Vegas A for a taste test and I'll try to figure out which is which.... That's only as long as I get to toss the Vegas A before the test (and I don't gotta carefully examine them to figure which is which...) ;)

The Volusianator said:
ggiese said:
Yup... Very true... You're new here and you don't know CC's past... ;)
Click to expand...
LOL, true as that is, I've gotten PM's from over 20 CP'ers today...so I'm learning fast. ;) :)
Click to expand...



WOW!!! You got nearly a thousand posts and you've only been here about a month!!! This thread keeps going the way it is, you're going to top a 1,000 after today!!! Congrats!!! :thumbs:



BTW - after receiving the PM's - you any wiser???
 
Actually I sold every Davidoff I had earlier this week in a post here on CP. So I can't help you there my good man, sorry.
 
The Volusianator said:
Actually I sold every Davidoff I had earlier this week in a post here on CP. So I can't help you there my good man, sorry.
Click to expand...



Thankfully my local B&M has every one available...



But honestly there's a awfully good reason why Davidoff's are consistently selling for about $20 each, while the Vegas A's are consistently $2... Some like Boone's Farm, while others like Chateau Rothschild... ;)
 
The Volusianator said:
ggiese said:
Yup... Very true... You're new here and you don't know CC's past... ;)
Click to expand...
LOL, true as that is, I've gotten PM's from over 20 CP'ers today...so I'm learning fast. ;) :)
Click to expand...
Aaaaah. The Super Secret Society of PM Support strikes again! OVER 20 PMs you say??? I've never gotten 20 PMs in one day at any point in my history here. That is fuggin' amazing... or you are lying...

I'm holding up a finger pal... guess which one.

NA
 
SamClemmons said:
The Volusianator said:
ggiese said:
Yup... Very true... You're new here and you don't know CC's past... ;)
Click to expand...
LOL, true as that is, I've gotten PM's from over 20 CP'ers today...so I'm learning fast. ;) :)
Click to expand...
Aaaaah. The Super Secret Society of PM Support strikes again! OVER 20 PMs you say??? I've never gotten 20 PMs in one day at any point in my history here. That is fuggin' amazing... or you are lying...

I'm holding up a finger pal... guess which one.

NA
Click to expand...
Sam if the "P" in PM didnt stand for Private, I'd forward each and every one of them to you. Unfortunatley it does stand for Private. Funny how even though I'm a noob, and admittingly not as well versed as nearly everone else here on CP, members who I've not seen since I got here (and with 1000 posts in less than 3 months I've seen quite a few posts) have been coming out of the woodwork since CC and I had a dissagreement. I guess the "posse of CC's followers that I was told about is quite evident. Not that it matters to me, I can't be bantered into an argument I don't want to get into.

Thanks for telling me I'm No.1 though! :laugh:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top