CgarDan
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jun 18, 2006
- Messages
- 6,011
This will be a fun and simple experiment to see how we rate cigars
Here is the point system
Total points = 100. Construction - 30 points. Flavor profile - 40 points. Complexity - 20 points. Esthetics/appearance - 10 points
There will be 5 cigars sent to the participants. Once you are done with smoking the cigar just PM me your rating with a number given to each of the 4 categories above. Feel free to add a simple review if you wish - nothing complex just what you liked and what you did not
I will send the cigars the week of January 9th. Total purchase will not exceed $75 including shipping.
Let’s have the rating deadline as end of Feb. this will give everyone a month and a half to do this Once I have the ratings from everyone I will post the average rating for that cigar and any comments given. Will also keep a spreadsheet if someone wants to see full data
Participants so far:
1) @CigarStone
2) @Pugman1943
3) @CBoukal
4) @cabaiguan juan
5) @lherzolite
6) @Gavin
7) @JoeMO
8) @SKYDIVNEKD
9) @Nate1977
10) @H. Vachon
11) @drunkfish3
12) @cohibasurfer
13) @Le Primauguet
14) @Smokemorestressless
15) @thinde
Would love to have 2 more people to do this with the bands on to see if there is any difference in rating for both methods
Let’s keep the total participants at no more than 20
I already bought 2 boxes and will post the total once I acquire the remaining boxes
Let me know if I missed anyone
Here is the point system
Total points = 100. Construction - 30 points. Flavor profile - 40 points. Complexity - 20 points. Esthetics/appearance - 10 points
There will be 5 cigars sent to the participants. Once you are done with smoking the cigar just PM me your rating with a number given to each of the 4 categories above. Feel free to add a simple review if you wish - nothing complex just what you liked and what you did not
I will send the cigars the week of January 9th. Total purchase will not exceed $75 including shipping.
Let’s have the rating deadline as end of Feb. this will give everyone a month and a half to do this Once I have the ratings from everyone I will post the average rating for that cigar and any comments given. Will also keep a spreadsheet if someone wants to see full data
Participants so far:
1) @CigarStone
2) @Pugman1943
3) @CBoukal
4) @cabaiguan juan
5) @lherzolite
6) @Gavin
7) @JoeMO
8) @SKYDIVNEKD
9) @Nate1977
10) @H. Vachon
11) @drunkfish3
12) @cohibasurfer
13) @Le Primauguet
14) @Smokemorestressless
15) @thinde
Would love to have 2 more people to do this with the bands on to see if there is any difference in rating for both methods
Let’s keep the total participants at no more than 20
I already bought 2 boxes and will post the total once I acquire the remaining boxes
Let me know if I missed anyone
