You could try a Hearth and Home sampler from the website you've already linked to (it's in the bulk tobacco section). Go through the descriptions and just pick some that sound good. The tobacco is excellent and the blends are very good quality. Flavor, of course, is subjective.
My favorites:
Sunjammer
Namaste'
Old Companion
Larry's Blend (Pretty heavy, but if you like more full bodied cigars it is VERY satisfying)
For the rest just pick whatever sounds good. If you call and order you can replace one of your 6 choices with Butternut Burley from Scotty's Blends. It is absolutely great and I"m really not a big Burley fan.
Good luck!
EDITED TO ADD: If you're looking for tinned tobacco The Froggy Went a Courtin' sampler is also a really good place to start in my opinion.
