Cigar pass rating experiment

[dawgie]

I’ll go with the bands on. I don’t have enough experience with enough different cigars for the band to really tell me much.

 

[BurnBerry]

19 all together now

Blind review
1) @cabaiguan juan
2) @Le Primauguet
3) @Gavin
4) @JoeMO
5) @CBoukal
6) @TexasTraveler
7) @wingman1974
8) @modo22
9) @BurnBerry
10) @Aalvord2
11) @TexEagle
12) @modo22 Friend
13) @drunkfish3
14) @JArtimez
15) @H. Vachon
16) @Nate1977
17) @Smokemorestressless
18) @dawgie34203

With bands on
1) @CgarDan


Anyone else willing to step up and rate these with bands on ?

I'll rate them with bands on if no one else wants to.

 

[CgarDan]

I'll rate them with bands on if no one else wants to.

I’ll go with the bands on. I don’t have enough experience with enough different cigars for the band to really tell me much.

Perfect appreciate your help guys https://www.cigarpass.com/community/threads/cigar-pass-rating-experiment.83043/post-1407626

 

[CgarDan]

19 all together now

Blind review
1) @cabaiguan juan
2) @Le Primauguet
3) @Gavin
4) @JoeMO
5) @CBoukal
6) @TexasTraveler
7) @wingman1974
8) @modo22
9) @Aalvord2
10) @TexEagle
11) @modo22 Friend
12) @drunkfish3
13) @JArtimez
14) @H. Vachon
15) @Nate1977
16) @Smokemorestressless


With bands on
1) @CgarDan
2) @BurnBerry
3) @dawgie34203

 

[Gavin]

19 all together now

Blind review
1) @cabaiguan juan
2) @Le Primauguet
3) @Gavin
4) @JoeMO
5) @CBoukal
6) @TexasTraveler
7) @wingman1974
8) @modo22
9) @Aalvord2
10) @TexEagle
11) @modo22 Friend
12) @drunkfish3
13) @JArtimez
14) @H. Vachon
15) @Nate1977
16) @Smokemorestressless


With bands on
1) @CgarDan
2) @BurnBerry
3) @dawgie34203

I probably throw off results with my prejudice against maduros. I should probably sit out.

 

[Nate1977]

I probably throw off results with my prejudice against maduros. I should probably sit out.

You probably should jump in

 

[Aalvord2]

19 all together now

Blind review
1) @cabaiguan juan
2) @Le Primauguet
3) @Gavin
4) @JoeMO
5) @CBoukal
6) @TexasTraveler
7) @wingman1974
8) @modo22
9) @BurnBerry
10) @Aalvord2
11) @TexEagle
12) @modo22 Friend
13) @drunkfish3
14) @JArtimez
15) @H. Vachon
16) @Nate1977
17) @Smokemorestressless
18) @dawgie34203

With bands on
1) @CgarDan


Anyone else willing to step up and rate these with bands on ?

I’ll hop in for bands on if needed.

 

[TexasTraveler]

I can do bands on or off

 

[CgarDan]

I think 3 with bands on is enough. But if anyone else want to join with bands off I think 1 more spot is open to make even 20

 

[CgarDan]

@member

Cigars purchased. Should land this week I think. Once it’s all here I will start a new thread

@Aalvord2 @JArtimez @dawgie34203 @BurnBerry please PM me your addys. @modo22 i am assuming I am sending your friends to you ?

 

[modo22]

@member

Cigars purchased. Should land this week I think. Once it’s all here I will start a new thread

@Aalvord2 @JArtimez @dawgie34203 @BurnBerry please PM me your addys. @modo22 i am assuming I am sending your friends to you ?

Yes

 

[Johnny B]

If no one else is in, I’ll be the control.

 

[CgarDan]

If no one else is in, I’ll be the control.

Perfect. I have 1 spot left But it’s up to you if you want to do bands on it off. We have 2 more besides myself. Your call

 

[Johnny B]

Whichever works for the greater good.

Do the participants learn how others rank each cigar?

 

[CgarDan]

Whichever works for the greater good.

Do the participants learn how others rank each cigar?

Of course once everyone is done with ranking a particular cigar I post the results